Here is a list of old greats I wouldn't mind seeing on the game from my usual countdown thread posts:

Anthony Carter, WR,
Deion Sanders, CB,
Joe Montana, QB,
Brett Favre, QB,
Robbie Bosco, QB,
Danny Wuerffel, QB,
Davy O'Brien, QB,
Vince Young, QB,
Matt Leinert, QB,
Roger Staubach, QB,
Dan Marino, QB,
Don Hutson, DE,
Tommy Frazier, QB,
Gary Beban, QB,
Charlie Ward, QB,
Archie Manning, QB,
Eric Dickerson, HB,
Earl Campbell, HB,
Barry Sanders, HB,
Doug Floutie, QB,
Jim Swink, RB,
Nile Kinnick, HB,
Tommy McDonald, HB,
Riley Smith, QB/FB
Eddie George, HB,
Anthony Davis, HB,
Eric Turner, S,
Mike Rozier, HB,
Vic Janowicz, HB,
Tony Dorsett, HB,
Herschel Walker, HB,
Felix Blanchard, FB,
Steve Owens, HB,
Doak Walker, HB,
George Rogers, HB,
John Kimbrough, FB,
Howard Cassady, HB/DB,
Glenn Davis, HB,
Ronnie Lott, S,
Terry Kinard, S,
Jim Brown, HB,
Archie Griffin, HB,
Bob Feruson, FB,
Bennie Oosterbaan, DE,
Angelo Bertelli, QB,
Bob Chappuis, HB,
Dick Butkus, LB,
Kurt Burris, C,
Harry Gilmer, Qb,
Randy Gradishar, LB,
Lee Roy Jordan, LB,
Marvin Jones, LB,
Michael Barrow, LB,
Steve Kiner, LB,
Peter Boulware, LB,
Alex Agase, G, /
Tommy Nobis, LB/G,
Jim Lynch, LB,
Jim Parker, G,
Mike Singletary, LB,
Bob Brown, G,
Greg Roberts, G,
George Gipp, HB,
Russell Maryland, DT,
Mike Reid, DT,
Tom Brown, G,
Bob Gain, T/G,
Merlin Olsen, T,
Bronko Nagurski, FB/DT,
John Hannah, G/T,
John Hicks, T,
Orlando Pace, T,
Warren Sapp, DT,
Red Grange, HB,
Bruce Smith, DT,
Rick Bryan, DT,
George Connor, T,
Leon Hart, TE,
Richard Wood, LB,
Jerry Robinsin, LB,
Jim Seymour, WR,
Courtney Brown, DE,
Bill Carpenter, TE,
Keith Jackson, TE,
Ross Browner, DE,
George Webster, LB,
Doug Atkins, T,
Tony Casillas, DT,
Lee Roy Selmon, DT,
Randy White, DT,
Bubba Smith, DE,
Daniel Stubbs, DT,
Cornelius Bennett, LB,
Tom Harmon, HB,
Hugh Green, DE,