I think 2K11 was a nice step up from 2K10 except in one area - a rigid hitting system. In 2K11 every outside pitch had to be hit to the opposite field. Every inside pitch had to be pulled. It was far too rigid, unrealistic and made the game boring. Plus I hated seeing a ton of opposite field HRs that happen because of this system. 2K11 still had its share of bugs but I did think it was better. My brother got 2K12 and likes My Player although I've heard 2K12 is VERY similar to 2K11.