I hated the r-stick kicking when they first added it because it was ridiculously easy and sliders didn't work much to fix it. But the last two years in NCAA the accuracy slider has been really good. I've got human accuracy at 30 and I made around 60% of my kicks I think. Ian said they wanted to make kicking harder by changing to this meter but it seems he made it easier from what I'm reading. Why not just reduce the default accuracy more? At 50 it IS too easy to make kicks. Drop it a bunch and it's not. Furthermore, why not have the option for either kicking system? Doesn't Tiger Woods let you choose from buttons or analog?