• NCAA Settles Keller Lawsuit; EA Talks Conditions for NCAA Football Return

    As the O'Bannon lawsuit versus the NCAA continues, the NCAA has reached a $20M settlement with the plaintiffs in the Sam Keller lawsuit. The Keller case was to be heard in March 2015 and the settlement will distribute $20 million to “certain Division I men’s basketball and Division I Bowl Subdivision football student-athletes who attended certain institutions during the years the games were sold.”

    “With the games no longer in production and the plaintiffs settling their claims with EA and the Collegiate Licensing Company, the NCAA viewed a settlement now as an appropriate opportunity to provide complete closure to the video game plaintiffs,” said NCAA Chief Legal Officer Donald Remy.

    Electronic Arts and the Collegiate Licensing Company finalized a $40M settlement with a series of plaintiffs in late May.

    The O'Bannon lawsuit does not feature the plantiffs looking for monetary damages, but rather changes to the current collegiate model. Continue on for more on this lawsuit as well as comments from Peter Moore on what it would take for the NCAA Football franchise to return.

    SI.com legal expert Michael McCann offered his thoughts on why the NCAA may have settled in the case:

    - Game Informer visited with EA SPORTS Chief Operating Officer Peter Moore and asked what it would take for the NCAA Football franchise to return:

    "We've always said that we'd monitor the situation," Moore says.

    We asked if there were specific things that would signal an all-clear to pursue the franchise again. "The development teams need to understand what they can and cannot do, and then it becomes a financial thing," Moore tells us. "If it costs you more to develop and pay for the players and what have you than you believe that you can sell, that's not fair to the [development] teams. They need to have an ongoing concern."

    In order to get to the point where EA is looking at costs though, Moore expects that systemic change would be necessary across the multi-billion dollar college sports industry. "I think this thing gets bigger than us and our industry before it settles itself down," he says. "We'll step back and watch this thing develop."


    UPDATE - From testimony at the O'Bannon v. NCAA lawsuit on Wednesday:

    Joel Linzner of Electronic Arts, which suspended its successful football video game series after being sued for not paying former players whose images it was accused of using without permission, said yesterday the company would welcome resurrecting the product.

    “If there was an economically efficient way to do it and no rules prohibited it, we would be interested,” Linzner said.


    - ESPN has written a lengthy piece on "Why You Should Know (Judge) Claudia Wilken."

    - Big Ten Conference Commissioner Jim Delaney believes that the existing lawsuits versus the NCAA will be settled in two to three years.
    Comments 76 Comments
    1. souljahbill's Avatar
      souljahbill -
      It appears that it's all a matter of who you root for. If your school is in a power conference, you may be more easily swayed by Big 5 game. If you're all about the little guys, it's all or nothing.
    1. ram29jackson's Avatar
      ram29jackson -
      http://deadspin.com/the-one-fuck-up-...ium=socialflow


      Astonishingly, an organization that tells us to think of it as "a marching band celebrating student-athletes in everything they do" did not call a single … wait for it … student-athlete. Two of the NCAA's four pre-competitive justifications for prohibiting compensation are that consumer demand of college sports is dependent on maintaining amateurism and that amateurism rules promote an integration of academics and athletics. Who could possibly be more qualified to speak to the merits of amateurism than a successful former amateur athlete?

      To be fair to the NCAA, the judge hearing the case previously ruled that any college athlete who has appeared in televised game footage since 2005 was automatically a class-action plaintiff, and therefore could not be called to testify on behalf of the defense. Still, out of all the thousands of athletes that played college sports before 2005, the best the NCAA could come up with was Jim Delany, a former North Carolina point guard who played in the '60s, a former Kent State basketball player from the '70s named Chris Plonsky, and Diane Dickman, who played college golf in the '80s for Tulsa.

      Here are some fun facts about those three pro-NCAA former student-athletes: Jim Delany is the current commissioner of the Big Ten, Chris Plonsky is the current athletics director at Texas, and Diane Dickman is the NCAA's current director of academic and membership affairs.

      Consider how stupid this makes the NCAA look. According to the NCAA's Division I manual, a college athlete's participation in sports should be "Motivated primarily by education and by the physical, mental and social benefits to be derived." And yet Emmert and his goons couldn't find a single "student-athlete" who does not currently have a financial stake in the NCAA's continued existence to take the stand and plainly state, "Yes, I got into this for the education as well as the physical, mental and social benefits to be derived."
    1. JeffHCross's Avatar
      JeffHCross -
      To all of you talking about playing a game with generic players, and the possibility of it allowing editing that could make teams more like real teams ... remember that Backbreaker was initially billed as a game that would allow full customization. It didn't have an NFL license, but would allow you to customize it to your heart's content.

      A mere threat of a lawsuit from the NFL killed off that feature before the game was ever released.

      I think EA would be rather gunshy with anything generic. The only likelihood I see of a generic game with customization ability getting released is if it's by a company that simply doesn't think it will make enough waves to get sued.
    1. Orbmik's Avatar
      Orbmik -
      Just started a new dynasty on the ps3, and this is one the reasons why I didn't buy a ps4. Because I only play Madden & NCAA, what's the point. I'd rather buy another ps3 to backup the one I already have. I know this is whishful thinking, but, you think we'll be able to roll over the grad class to M15? This is really a sad time 4 me, gotta wait until August to get a new football game
    1. JeffHCross's Avatar
      JeffHCross -
      SCOTUS denies EA appeal, will not hear case.

      http://www.courthousenews.com/2014/10/02/72085.htm
    1. cdj's Avatar
      cdj -
    1. steelerfan's Avatar
      steelerfan -
    1. cdj's Avatar
      cdj -
    1. SmoothPancakes's Avatar
      SmoothPancakes -
      Wow. $74, $270, $4,324, $5,000 or $15,000. Hope it was worth destroying the entire series jackasses.

      #TheScriptIsDead
    1. cdj's Avatar
      cdj -
      Quote Originally Posted by SmoothPancakes View Post
      Wow. $74, $270, $4,324, $5,000 or $15,000. Hope it was worth destroying the entire series jackasses.

      #TheScriptIsDead
      Well, for the lawyers it was definitely worth it. They'd likely love to do it again.

      If I understand Solomon correctly, less than 10% of those eligible joined the class-action suit. I wonder how that compares to the average % in similar suits.
    1. cdj's Avatar
      cdj -
    1. JeffHCross's Avatar
      JeffHCross -
      Quote Originally Posted by cdj View Post
      Well, for the lawyers it was definitely worth it. They'd likely love to do it again.

      If I understand Solomon correctly, less than 10% of those eligible joined the class-action suit. I wonder how that compares to the average % in similar suits.
      Along the same lines, I'm pretty sure nobody involved actually wanted to kill the series ... maybe a few people thought it was so problematic that they wanted to see the series end ... but I think Keller and others just wanted some compensation for the fact that they were being used without permission.

      The lawyers, clearly, were the ones truly interested in a big pay day. What a joke.
    1. SmoothPancakes's Avatar
      SmoothPancakes -
      Yeah, the lawyers made out with a nice big fat payday.

      #TheScriptIsDead
    1. souljahbill's Avatar
      souljahbill -
      CLW, can we now sue Keller and O'Bannon and the lawyers for taking the game away from us? They denied my right to pursue happiness as stated in the Declaration of Independence
    1. steelerfan's Avatar
      steelerfan -
    1. skipwondah33's Avatar
      skipwondah33 -
      lol

      20,000 plus hours! Good lord at $900 an hour haha